Ms. Stevens fears that the result of this legislation that there will be natural parents who have no choice but to live their lives in fear of their secret being found out by other members of their family or friends.
The article goes on to say that there are adopted children who as adults may be unaware that they had been adopted and are happy with their lives the way they have chosen to live them without knowing their natural parents.
The article discusses the application filed in the Ontario Superior Court last October they argue by amending the province’s Vital Statistics Act to disclose adoption related records without the other person’s consent, the Adoption Information Disclosure Act provides a “unilateral and presumptive right to access.” The application further states by impinging on the applicants right to have their personal information remain private be removing their right to control the dissemination of personal information and through an adoption disclosure regime that results in state imposed psychological harm. The law violates the rights to security of the person and the liberty found under section 7 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
SPONSOR
The article discusses how the government’s position is that adoption can be stigmatizing and that part of the stigmatization is when you keep it all secret so they are going to let natural parents and adoptees have access to each other’s records.
Some are questioning why the government is undoing the promise of confidentiality made decades ago and feel that they have a reasonable expectation of privacy under the charter.
Other provinces in Canada that has enacted similar legislation has included a veto where one of the parties involved in the adoption can decline to have their personal information share with either their natural parents or the child put up for adoption.