Adoption Search Blog

06/29/06

Is Criticizing Adoption Off Limits? - Part 2

Posted by : Jan Baker in Adoption Search Blog at 07:14 am , 318 words, 39 views  
Categories: General Issues, Adoption in the Media


When people question the despicable practices in Russia and other countries, they are sometimes attacked as anti-adoption. For those who fight to improve bad practices in certain foreign countries, some are inclined to call them anti-adoption.

Is it really fair to label people who want to reform adoption either domestically or internationally as anti-adoption? Not to me, it isn’t. But, what about all those poor children in the bleak orphanages of the world that will not be adopted because some “do-gooder” wants to clean up adoption practices in a specific country? Believe me, I feel for children growing up in orphanages. However,does that mean we maintain lax standards and policies to get more children adopted? Do we relax and throw aside any standards so that more children get adopted no matter who adopts them? In those countries where parents are supposed to send reports on adopted children, parents should be honoring their committments.

SPONSOR
http://www.omnitrace.com/Birth-Family.html

Blame the corrupt people who create, support and practice the unethical adoption policies, not those who are trying to clean them up. Put some of the blame on adoptive parents who support agencies known to be “iffy”.

I simply cannot justify directing anger at those who are seeking to make adoption better. Or is it adoption full force, ethics be dammed? Sometimes I wonder.

There is something I have been noticing lately. It appears to me that when people criticize any aspect of adoption, some people are immediately ready to brand that person "anti-adoption". Pitchforks suddenly appear and a posse of "adoption is perfect" triad members gather. They appear chomping at the bit, ready to pounce on the poor unsuspecting soul who unwittingly committed a grave sin by criticizing adoption.

This tendency to condemn those who speak ill of adoption sometimes happens in all types of adoption. For the moment though, I am speaking about when it occurs in discussions about international adoptions.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Angela [Member] Email · http://ukraine.adoptionblogs.com/
I love this blog and part 1. You are asking great questions.

It is fine to question and great when people point out bad things.

But there is emotional baggage behind the Baroness for example. She has too many personal habits that remind me of Joe McCarthy.

While she was trying to shutdown Romanian adoption she has this "secret" documentation that would blow the lid off. She could prove the children were being bought and sold for their organs.

And when pushed to provide these documents... to prove her statements. She magically didn't any documents.

If anyone disagrees with the Baroness.. then they are out to get her. So the newspaper that asked for her "proof" was labeled as behaving inappropriately.

She is always right and everyone else is wrong. She got into a nasty exchange on various web sites with a Czech newspaper recently. She claimed X (not directly related to Romanian adoption). The newspaper asked her to prove. Now she is the martyr.

Anyway this comment has gotten long. I will stop now and try to answer again later.
PermalinkPermalink 06/30/06 @ 12:05
Comment from: Angela [Member] Email · http://ukraine.adoptionblogs.com/
Oops.. I meant to add

The torches and pitchforks come out for the Baroness because she seems to ask for it/generate it.

Much of the controversy that centers around her.. She started it. I have wondered if she has some type of personality disorder where everything has to be about her.
PermalinkPermalink 06/30/06 @ 12:09
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthfamily-search.adoptionblogs.com/
Thanks Angela, I always appreciate your voice of reason. I don't know much about the Baroness except what was blogged about her recently. You could be completely right about her. I wasn't defending her - I don't know her. Just hate the idea of criticizing those who do want to make adoption better. Maybe she does bring out the pitchforks, etc. by her ways?
PermalinkPermalink 06/30/06 @ 13:08
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

http://www.omnitrace.com

Misc

Subscribe to Adoption Search Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Jenna Hatfield Email
  • Guest Users: 133